55 F
Fort Worth
Monday, October 26, 2020
Government Federal judge upholds Texas' partisan statewide judicial elections system

Federal judge upholds Texas’ partisan statewide judicial elections system

Other News

Who killed Sweden’s prime minister? 1986 assassination of Olof Palme is finally solved – maybe

Andrew Nestingen, University of Washington It took 34 years,...

Fort Worth Police seeking man who robbed diners on Southside restaurant patio

Fort Worth Police are seeking a man who robbed diners at an outdoor patio on Hemphill Street on the city's Southside.

Authorities find 2 abducted girls after 2 boys are killed

By HEATHER HOLLINGSWORTH The Associated PressMISSION, Kan. (AP) — Authorities found two girls who were abducted from a Kansas home where two...

Second whistleblower fired from Texas attorney general’s office after accusing Ken Paxton of bribery

By Emma Platoff, The Texas Tribune Oct. 22, 2020 "Second whistleblower fired from Texas...

Texas Tribune

September 12, 2018

A federal judge has rejected a race-based challenge to the way Texans fill seats on the state’s highest courts. 

U.S. District Judge Nelva Gonzales Ramos of Corpus Christi handed the state of Texas a win Wednesday, writing that its current method for electing judges to the Texas Supreme Court and the Court of Criminal Appeals does not violate federal safeguards for voters of color. 

The system does dilute the power of Hispanic voters, Ramos wrote. But it’s not clear that “race rather than partisanship” explains why Hispanic voters’ preferred candidates tend to lose at the polls. 

Seven Hispanic voters and a community organization sued the state in 2016, arguing that Texas’ statewide judicial election system violates the federal Voting Rights Act because it weakens Hispanic voters’ political clout and keeps them from electing their preferred candidates. Both high courts have been entirely dominated by Republicans for more than two decades, and both courts remain overwhelmingly white. 

The state, meanwhile, argued that the makeup of the courts is explained by changing political preferences. Lawyers from the Texas Attorney General’s Office pointed out that the two high courts have seen a complete partisan shift in the last four decades: Democrats dominated the courts until the mid-1990s. 

“Partisanship explains these patterns — not race,” Patrick Sweeten, the state’s lead attorney, said during a February trial in Ramos’ courtroom. 

Lawyers for the plaintiffs pointed to a long history of Hispanic judges losing races for the Texas Supreme Court and Court of Criminal Appeals — even with the advantage of incumbency. Voters’ preferred candidates don’t have to be of their same race or ethnicity, but that is often the case for Latino voters, they argued. 

“The courts cannot be the great equalizer of our social fabric when one group — Latinos — are disadvantaged in the election process,” Jose Garza, an attorney representing the voters, told Ramos in February. 

The plaintiffs had proposed that Texas adopt a single-member district approach, carving up the state geographically to allow for Hispanic-majority voting districts. In her Wednesday ruling, Ramos conceded it would be possible to remedy the Hispanic voters’ “electoral disadvantage” by switching to single-member elections. But she declined to order that change because the voters had failed to prove that the obstacles they faced to electing their preferred candidates were “on account of race.” 

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton cheered the news.  

“Texans have been choosing the courts’ highest appellate judges in statewide elections for 142 years, and this system supports the state’s interest in maintaining judicial accountability and independence,” Paxton said in a statement.  

“Federal judge upholds Texas’ partisan statewide judicial elections system” was first published at by The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan media organization that informs Texans — and engages with them — about public policy, politics, government and statewide issues.

Latest News

Senate votes to advance Barrett; confirmation expected Monday

By LISA MASCARO AP Congressional CorrespondentWASHINGTON (AP) — Senate Republicans voted overwhelmingly Sunday to advance Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett toward...

Kamala Harris to make campaign stop in Texas

By Alex Samuels, The Texas Tribune Oct. 25, 2020 "Kamala Harris to make campaign...

El Paso officials ask residents to stay home for two weeks as COVID-19 hospitalizations surge

By Cassandra Pollock and Julián Aguilar, The Texas Tribune Oct. 25, 2020 "El Paso...

Beyond the Needle: Probability experts assess 2020 race

By DAVID BAUDER AP Media WriterNEW YORK (AP) — The one thing most likely to conjure nightmares of the 2016 election night...

Early vote total exceeds 2016; GOP chips at Dems’ advantage

By NICHOLAS RICCARDI and ANGELIKI KASTANIS Associated PressWith nine days before Election Day, more people already have cast ballots in this year's...