55 F
Fort Worth
Monday, October 26, 2020
Government Indigent defense idea to get first test in Texas

Indigent defense idea to get first test in Texas

Other News

Who killed Sweden’s prime minister? 1986 assassination of Olof Palme is finally solved – maybe

Andrew Nestingen, University of Washington It took 34 years,...

Fort Worth Police seeking man who robbed diners on Southside restaurant patio

Fort Worth Police are seeking a man who robbed diners at an outdoor patio on Hemphill Street on the city's Southside.

Authorities find 2 abducted girls after 2 boys are killed

By HEATHER HOLLINGSWORTH The Associated PressMISSION, Kan. (AP) — Authorities found two girls who were abducted from a Kansas home where two...

Second whistleblower fired from Texas attorney general’s office after accusing Ken Paxton of bribery

By Emma Platoff, The Texas Tribune Oct. 22, 2020 "Second whistleblower fired from Texas...
Robert Francis
Robert Francis
Robert is a Fort Worth native and longtime editor of the Fort Worth Business Press. He is a former president of the local Society of Professional Journalists and was a freelancer for a variety of newspapers, weeklies and magazines, including American Way, BrandWeek and InformatonWeek. A graduate of TCU, Robert has held a variety of writing and editing positions at publications such as the Grand Prairie Daily News and InfoWorld. He is also a musician and playwright.

JUAN A. LOZANO, Associated Press

NEW BRAUNFELS, Texas (AP) — Tommy Vaughn knows his clients may be distrustful when a court appoints him to handle their case. Without enough money to hire their own lawyer, defendants are often suspicious that court-appointed attorneys will provide a poor defense or just try to coerce a quick guilty plea.

“I kind of assume that’s what they’re thinking when I first meet them,” said Vaughn, who has worked as a defense attorney in Texas for 2½ years.

The issue of trust has long been part of a larger discussion about the quality of indigent defense in the U.S. Now, the Central Texas county where Vaughn works will be the first in the country to give these individuals the ability to choose their own attorneys at the government’s expense.

It’s part of a pilot program in Comal County that could determine whether the idea could be adopted in other jurisdictions and provide a new wrinkle to how the Sixth and Fourteenth Amendments are exercised.

Under the new system, a defendant who is declared indigent will be given a list of 30 to 50 attorneys who have been approved by the county. An individual will have a day to make a choice.

Legal experts have suggested that defendants will be more invested in their cases, and there will be more accountability for attorneys.

“When the attorney has to earn the business for these indigent defense appointments, as opposed to being their turn in the rotation, they have new and stronger incentives to provide good quality services,” said Edwin Colfax, project manager for the Texas Indigent Defense Commission, which gave Comal County a $200,000 grant for the program, tentatively set to begin Jan. 12.

In countries such as Australia, Canada and England, indigent defendants have for years been able to choose their own lawyer.

In Texas, the most common indigent defense model is the “wheel” system, where judges appoint whichever lawyer on a previously approved list is next up on the rotation. Some court systems in Texas and across the country also use public defender offices or contract with attorneys or law firms to provide indigent defense services.

The commission envisions the idea working in Comal partly because of its manageable size. The county has about 118,000 residents between Austin and San Antonio.

It’s unclear how well the concept would work in larger jurisdictions with an increased number of cases and possible issues with determining how defendants would be informed about the quality of attorneys. The program will be tested for a year.

Alex Bunin, chief public defender with the Harris County Public Defender’s Office in Houston, said attorney choice could be tried in large counties, but issues such as funding for adequate pay, investigative services and other resources would have to be addressed.

Otherwise, the idea “will only be a novelty,” he said.

San Antonio resident Valerie Williams said she’s had mixed success with appointed attorneys.

Williams said she was arrested for driving while intoxicated in 2002 and was convicted, placed on probation and fined $2,000 after her court-appointed attorney did little work. Recently, another court-appointed attorney in Comal County managed to get her DWI and drug charges dismissed.

“I think (Comal County’s program) would make people feel a little more confident about what they are going through,” said Williams, 40.

Over the years, indigent defense has been much criticized across the U.S., in part because of underfunding. Court-appointed attorneys usually earn far less than privately hired lawyers.

Dib Waldrip, a judge in Comal County, said he’s unsure simply “throwing money” at indigent defense will fix its problems and is looking forward to finding out if attorney choice can make courts more efficient.

Ernie Lewis, executive director of the National Association for Public Defense, said any improvements from attorney choice won’t mean much without additional funding to provide attorneys with resources to mount strong defenses.

“A good public defender system is going to be a check on an overaggressive police department or a prison system that is depriving inmates of their fundamental human rights,” said Lewis, who ran Kentucky’s public defender system for 12 years. “We as a society have to have good, adequately funded, high-quality public defender systems if it’s going to play those roles.”


Latest News

Senate votes to advance Barrett; confirmation expected Monday

By LISA MASCARO AP Congressional CorrespondentWASHINGTON (AP) — Senate Republicans voted overwhelmingly Sunday to advance Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett toward...

Kamala Harris to make campaign stop in Texas

By Alex Samuels, The Texas Tribune Oct. 25, 2020 "Kamala Harris to make campaign...

El Paso officials ask residents to stay home for two weeks as COVID-19 hospitalizations surge

By Cassandra Pollock and Julián Aguilar, The Texas Tribune Oct. 25, 2020 "El Paso...

Beyond the Needle: Probability experts assess 2020 race

By DAVID BAUDER AP Media WriterNEW YORK (AP) — The one thing most likely to conjure nightmares of the 2016 election night...

Early vote total exceeds 2016; GOP chips at Dems’ advantage

By NICHOLAS RICCARDI and ANGELIKI KASTANIS Associated PressWith nine days before Election Day, more people already have cast ballots in this year's...